I see a lot of Dog lovers on the internet,
(I don't me the four legged kind)
I mean among Pink Floyd fans.
I keep telling myself I MUST be missing something
and I keep trying and trying but to no avail.
For a million reason I suppose one being my old French Proverb
Les gouts et les couleurs ne sont pas a discuter
colloquially tranlated as "to each his own"
One big reason would be time frame
1967 -1970 five albums that I mostly missed
1967 Piper at the Gates of Dawn
1968 A Saucerful of Secrets
1969 More
1969 Ummagumma
1970 Atom Heart Mother
Still in school for most of that time between 11 and 14 years old
I vaguely remember the cool kids in my school
(of which I wasn't part of)
playing Ummagumma somewhere.
now by 1970 I was out of school making "some" money
and Meddle might have been the first album I ever bought even though I think this memory might be forged:
K-Tel 24 Dynamic Hits at $1.99 just doesn't sound so glamorous! LOL
But I vividly remember though by the time I had my 2nd job and moved on to my own apartment, bought my Electrohome Apollo 860 record player on a Household Finance
"arm and a leg" interest rate
on the 6 months $199 loan.
My 2nd job was also my introduction to drugs: my first job being working 6 months with my dad at $20 a week. New job paid $1.65 an hour.
So back to my short time in apartment I vividly remember Seamus howling all night long as I was in different states of consciousness.
IIRC it would have been mescaline back then by the cap still at this time.
Funny thing with old record players is that if you had the arm up but no record following the record player would assume you were playing a 45 RPM and start somewhere in the middle of an LP.
So NO "One of These Days"
but lots of Seamus all night long.
Would be curious to know where exactly the needle fell back then? Anyone?
So I have a tender spot for Meddle as my first love kind of.
Then my short years left moved on quickly again in different states of consciousness from acid to crystal meth from Led Zep to Deep Purple stopping here and there for Black Sabbath and Alice Cooper forgetting many I am sure.
Came August the 12th 1976 I was "retired" and even more "retired on October 12th 1976 where I ended up in a cult for many years that did not listen to all this devil music.
So I totally missed Animals in its time.
Comfortably Numb is 1000 times better than Dogs.
Echoes beats the shit out of Dogs.
Hell! Marooned is better than Dogs.
Shine on You Crazy Diamonds is 999 times better than Dogs.
Seamus is prolly the best dogs of them all :)
The whole DSOTM leaves Dogs in a trail of dust.
WYWH also
MY Great Four are very different than most I guess
I am not a huge fan at all of the Wall 'cept for the greatest anthem to Smack and Numbness ever: Comfortably Numb arguably also the very best guitar solo ever written.
In no particular order my Great Four are
Meddle (first love oblige plus it is great)
DSOTM
WYWH
Division Bell (and I got to DB very late)
Some of the other stuff I may have never listened to I confess.
I gave a fair go to Animals and still trying to get the cult mania.
There is it seems to me a cultic approach to Animals.
Artsy fartsy fans who looked down on the hoi polloi who don't "get" them. It seems to me that some sheep have canine delusions. Or is it the Stockholm Syndrome now?
Anyway here is my tiny little worthless opinion among many others.
There are a gazillion factors in each of our lives that make us like one thing and dislike or not care for another.